Google Search plus Your World - bad for the internet? January 24
It’s fair to say that we all value content shared by people that we know, over just any Tim, Dick or Harry. This principle idea has been the catalyst for a number of innovations from Google over the past couple of years, with the aim of making search a more personalised experience for users.
When Google created their very own social network in the form of Google+ back in September 2011, they enabled people to create their ‘own little world’ on a Google platform; this has spawned their latest development in the ongoing search/social saga - ‘Google Search plus Your World’ - which launched a couple of weeks ago.
If (and it’s a big ‘if’, as we’ll talk about later) you are signed into a Google account and have a Google+ profile, you’ll be able to access the ‘personalised search’ feature. The crux of ‘Search plus Your World‘ is that it incorporates content from Google+ directly into your search results. Within the search results pages there are options to show personalised results; hide personalised results; and to just see personal results. It’s currently only available when searching on https://www.google.com/ in English but will undoubtedly be rolled out across the globe over the coming weeks and months.
The screengrab below shows a few of these features…

In full, the three elements to ‘Search plus Your World’ are:
1. Personal results
Content including posts and photos will be pulled from Google+ and included within the search results. For example, if you were searching for photos of somewhere you’d like to go on holiday, you may come across a photo that a friend (in one of your circles) took whilst they were on holiday there a couple of months ago and subsequently posted on Google+. You could then easily get in touch with your friend via Google+ to find out more about what they thought of it.
2. Profiles in search
If you start to type the name of someone in your Google+ circles, a number of predicted profiles will appear within the autocomplete box (although let’s hope you aren’t friends with a number of John Smiths). Once you’ve selected the person you were looking for, the results page will include their Google+ page (with recent activity), as well as other related web results such as twitter and LinkedIn profiles.
3. People & pages
When searching for a particular topic, you may see prominent people or pages from Google+ listed on the right-hand side. On Google’s official blog they have used the example of searching for the topic of [music], for which Britney Spears appears at the top - we’ll let you decide for yourselves if Google still need to do some tweaking here and there!
So, what impact will this have on search channels?
In order for users to see these new personalised search results they will need a Google account, a profile on Google+ and to be signed in when searching; this remains the major stumbling block, particularly as Google+ has a mere 60 million users compared with Facebook’s 800 million.
At present, the number of searches made by those logged in to a Google account is estimated to be between 10-15%; of that, only an estimated 20% of searches will be returning ‘Search plus Your World’ results.
In search, some markets will find it harder to attract clicks in a traditional manner from both paid and organic search as results are ‘polluted’ with Google’s own agenda, with social results effectively taking up positions in the search rankings that could otherwise have been showing ‘traditional’ results. So, brands will either have to embrace Google+ by posting content and encouraging their website visitors to +1 them…or increase their activity (and therefore spend!) in paid advertising. Or, indeed, do both!
Is ‘Search plus Your World’ a good thing?
Along with many of our search industry peers, we’re not convinced that content from Google+ should be ranking higher than ’standard’ natural search results. Should it be given prominence simply because it was posted on Google’s own social network?!
Given that Google already has a more than dominant share of the search market in the UK (which stands at 91.4% according to StatCounter), ‘Search plus Your World’ is adding fuel to the fire for those arguing that Google’s monopoly is bad for the Internet.
Twitter’s Alex Macgillivray declared that it was a “bad day for the Internet” and that search is “being warped” (by making it harder for people to find real-time information provided by Twitter) - with Google responding by saying that they were “surprised by Twitter’s comments” as “they chose not to renew their agreement with us” (a reference to the end of the deal which saw tweets included in Google Realtime Search results).

Time will tell
As with all new developments, time will tell as to whether this is going to be a game-changer or whether it’ll just die another slow death like other Google innovations (Buzz, Wave). But word is that Google employee bonuses are tied to the success of Google+ - so chances are that ‘Search plus Your World’ is here to stay and is a key part of the strategy to grow Google+. If it ever does compete seriously with Facebook in scale, then ‘Search plus Your World’ could well change the face of search.



